Chance missed
Mar 22nd, 2010 by Ian Hyde-Lay
Sunday, March 21
Definitely a ‘mental health’ day, with most of the players, now with their host families at King’s Hospital School, enjoying their first lie in on tour.
Team selection for the final match is discussed at length, with Fraser McGee and Reed Plasterer set for 1st XV debuts at prop and scrum half respectively. The fitness/health of fullback Eric Beban (groin) and flankers Eali Hopper (shin) Joe Furness (flu) remain a concern. Otherwise, while Luke McLoskey (shoulder), Nathan Bosworth (ribs) and Alex Economou (hamstring) are out, the rest of the squad is available to play.
Monday, March 22
Once again, the players are in school early. King’s Hospital is situated on a sprawling south Dublin campus, and, not surprisingly for an institution founded in 1669, has a bit of history behind it!! It is enjoying something of a resurgence on the rugby front under head coach Matt Jarvis, with this year’s 1st XV reaching the round of 16 in the prestigious Leinster Schools Cup before bowing out to eventual winners Clongowes.
The SMUS party spends the morning at the Guinness factory, very much enjoying a 2 hour tour around a facility and company founded in 1759 and so this year celebrating its 250 year anniversary!! The top of the seven story building offers a stunning panoramic view of Dublin. The lower floor exhibits take visitors through the history of the company, the vision of its founder Arthur Guinness, how the beer is actually produced and provides finally a lesson on ‘how to pour the perfect pint!!’
The seven floors are in the shape of a massive beer glass – one, we are informed, which would require 14.3 million pints of Guinness to fill from bottom to top!!
Lunch complete, it is back to King’s Hospital for the final tour match. Without question, fatigue has set in to a degree and thoughts are turning to home, but equally there is a determination to finish with a victory.
As it turns out, while Ingemar de Wet is able to make his first start of the tour and Hopper and Furness recover sufficiently well, Beban is not good to go. This necessitates a revamping of the backline, with Charlie Southwell moving to fullback, while Colin Smith and Marc vander Wal patrol the wings. The experiment of playing Alex Harvey in the backrow continues.
In the opening half, SMUS plays with the benefit of a strong, diagonal wind. Putting the ball through the phases well and initially controlling territory, the team first goes up 3-0 courtesy of a Southwell penalty goal and then, in the 21st minute, 8-0 after a superb line break and 35m gallop from player of the tour Alex Austin.
Unfortunately, this advantage is not pressed home. Inconsistent work on restarts and not using the wind (when the best of course of action is just to smash the ball long down the park) leaves SMUS trapped in its own half and defending far longer than should have been necessary during the first 35 minutes. Then, with more points absolutely vital, an ill judged quick tap negates the chance for an easy penalty kick at goal before some white line fever in the final seconds allows King’s off the hook with SMUS looking at a promising overlap scoring chance.
While the wind drops to some degree after the break, it remains a factor, and the King’s halfbacks make sure the game is played in the SMUS quarter of the field. Despite some excellent defence, the hosts manage two tries, one of which is converted, for a 12-8 lead.
Yet, SMUS refuses to go quietly. Mike Fuailefau is nearly away after snaring a loose ball, Southwell produces his usual array of mazy runs, Hopper, Wonjin Kim and Joe Shan take the ball on strongly. Yet the team cannot improve on its 8 first half points. An otherwise excellent referee fails to spot a cynical obstruction on a chasing vander Wal, and should have penalized for offside after the home fullback knocks under pressure in the shadow of his own posts. These two easy penalty kicks would have taken the score back to 14-12 SMUS.
King’s are clinical on returning to the SMUS end of the field, playing the ball through multiple phases and winning two deserved penalties. Both of these, though no gimmes by any stretch of the imagination given the conditions, are slotted home, with the second taking King’s ahead by more than one score at 18-8.
One last SMUS charge ends just meters short of the line, with the final whistle denying the team even the satisfaction of a consolation tally. Nonetheless, over the course of 70 minutes, the result is a fair one.
Post game presentations complete, the entire team and staff move to the nearby Liffey Clarion hotel. Time for a last get together, reflections and thoughts before the 24 hour marathon return to Canada via Newark and Seattle.
While the King’s Hospital match does represent a chance missed, there can be no denying that the entire squad has improved significantly in the past two weeks. While some annoying injuries blunt continuity of selection, others take the opportunity to shine, and, in the course of the upcoming domestic season, will provide critical depth.
Indeed, the overall development of the team will be immediately tested with The High School of Glasgow set to visit SMUS on April 6, while BC powerhouse Carson Graham will be in Victoria for a match on April 12.
Until then, adieu….


